Luminar 3 – With Libraries. First looks

by | Jan 2, 2019 | Uncategorized | 1 comment

Luminar 3 With Libraries was released recently and I’ve been playing with it for a while. Here’s my first impressions:

The Good

  • A reasonable image browser with a unique layout
  • It keeps itself up to date after you have told it the folder(s) where your images are
  • The RAW conversion is high quality, although it is not the best
  • The interface is easy to use
  • Price – currently £47.

The Bad

  • The image browser is not really configurable
  • The browser is slow, often painfully so
  • It doesn’t show any information about the image – not even the name or file type
  • The image browser treats RAW+JPEG as two separate files and doesn’t indicate which one is being displayed
  • Minimal EXIF/IPTC information displayed and only in the Edit screen
  • IPTC cannot be edited
  • External Applications cannot be launched from the Browser
  • Folders added to the browser after the initial import appear at the bottom of the browser tree

To be honest, I was expecting more from Luminar. This update has been a long, long time coming and it offers little more than a basic browser. I have experience with both using and writing Digital Asset Management software. I wrote PFS Manager (which received an 87% rating in Amateur Photographer magazine) and PFS Image Darkroom. I didn’t have a team of developers. It was just me. And my software was faster and had more features.

The Browser

Here is a screen shot of Luminar’s browser and also Photo Ninja’s and Exposure X4’s:

Luminar's Browser Luminar’s Browser
Photo Ninja's Browser Photo Ninja’s Browser
Exposure X4's browser Exposure X4’s browser

Photo Ninja’s browser is lightening fast and Exposure 3’s browser is no slouch either.

Conclusion

Luminar is a very good RAW processor, but it is not the best in class. I would rank Photo Ninja as better, followed by DXO Photo Lab 2. Luminar’s browser is nowhere near as good as Exposure X4’s and Photo Ninja’s is also better.

Hopefully Skylum will enhance the browser over the coming months. Their published roadmap  addresses some of its shortcomings. At the moment it is worth the price, but only as an investment for the future. But this is a highly competitive market and to compete you have to offer something compelling…

1 Comment

  1. Guillaume A

    Great short review, thank you ! Just reading the cons is enough for me – a major disappointment on my side, since i was being prepped for a little DAM revolution coming with Luminar 3.. I would also add the lack of local search – if such is absent – to the cons list. How could one leave this out when we talk about DAM / file management is beyond me. And this search should be able to search the exif, eg ISO, aperture, etc – a separate item in the cons list ..

    Reply

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related Posts

Topaz Gigapixel AI 6 – Time to Face the Truth?

Topaz Gigapixel AI 6 – Time to Face the Truth?

Readers of this blog will know I am a big fan of Topaz Gigapixel AI. I have owned it since version 1 and I would not enlarge a photo without it. For previous reviews, see here and here. Recently, I received a phone call from someone who wanted to make a mural of one of [...]

More Topaz Magic-Mask AI Released

Topaz Mask AI As I stated in yesterday's post, Topaz Labs seem to be the most innovative photo software company at the moment. They've restructured their software into two groups: Topaz Studio, which contains all their 'regular' plugins and enhancement tools. The AI range, their specialist tools. And now they've added AI Mask. I've played [...]

Upgrading to Windows 10

Windows 10 Upgrade is Still Free. I recently upgraded one of my computers to Windows 10. I know, I'm a late adopter. But Windows 7 was working fine for me and I didn't feel inclined to update it without good reason. I had to update it to test the new DXO PhotoLab 3, which won't [...]

An aid for blogging

ProWritingAid - a tool for bloggers and writers I've been writing this blog for over a year now and it's a very different discipline to taking and editing photographs. I find it harder. Until yesterday, my method was to write the post and then use Yoast's features to check my writing. That worked for shorter posts [...]

Topaz Gigapixel AI Vs Canon EF x2 Extender

I have tested Topaz Gigapixel AI before and concluded that it is the best image resize software. I now wanted to give it quite a stern challenge. How would it fare going up against a  top-rated teleconverter such as the Canon EF 2x Extender, Mark 3? The extender Canon's 2x extended attaches to some of their [...]

Affinity Photo – correction

In my previous reviews of this excellent software, I made a mistake regarding its focus stacking, saying that the individual layers in the stack cannot be edited. This is incorrect. See this Youtube video for details. To my mind Affinity is simply fantastic and it offers a real depth of features. But this mistake on [...]

Canon EOS R – Full Frame Mirrorless. Is it worth it?

I have used many APS-C mirrorless cameras, from the diminutive Canon EOS M100 to the medium sized Samsung NX500 to the SLR like Samsung NX1 and I have loved them all. But the appeal of 'full frame' cameras is strong. After all, full frame must mean better pictures, surely? Sadly, not. No camera will make [...]

A.I. Gigipixel 1.1 released.

I recently reviewed the initial release of A.I. Gigapixel and concluded it was a great Image Resize tool. Its main problems were the speed on low end graphics cards and it didn't support many low end graphics cards at all. This new release fixes the graphics card issue - the software will now run using your PC's CPU [...]

Instagram – what to do and what not to do…

My Instagram Page I use and love Instagram. My Instagram page is gaining new followers everyday. It's not as fast as I would like, but it is steady and the new users are sticking around. Like most of us, I've tried different strategies for building up my following and I'm going to share with you [...]

Hello photography world!

Hello Blogworld I thought it was time to start publishing some articles, reviews and photography news. So stay tuned - they'll be lots of good stuff here soon!

Don't miss the Black Friday deals from the best photo software vendors!

Try out their free trials.

DXO Photo Lab

DxO Photo Lab

The best RAW image converter, producing the highest possible quality results.

Topaz Photo AI

Topaz Photo AI

Three unbeatable AI post processing tools: Upscale, DeNoise, Sharpen. Nothing beats them.

Luminar NEO

Luminar Neo

A unique AI based RAW converter and image editor. Want creativity? Look no further.

Massive Black Friday savings announced!

Cookie Consent with Real Cookie Banner