Raw Converter Shootout Part #2 – Sharpening

by | Jun 27, 2018 | Photo Software Reviews | 0 comments

For part #1 click here.

This is part #2 of a series of posts regarding RAW image converters and their performance.

What’s being tested?

The converters being tested are:

The test image:

Original Image, no processing

The test

This part of the test looks at the converters’ ability to provide basic image corrections, in particular initial sharpening of the image. Smart RAW developers sharpen the image in stages – once during RAW processing, once after enhancing the image and once after sizing the image for print/display. The final step depends on the output medium – printed images tend to need more sharpening than ones displayed on a screen.

All the RAW converters being tested only allow for one sharpening step, with the exception of DXO, which has a specific camera/lens auto-sharpening step as well as ‘regular’ unsharp mask sharpening.

Personally, I don’t like unsharp mask sharpening, as it is too global in nature and lacks subtlety. Other photographers get on well with it. In any case, this stage of the Shootout does the following:

  • DXO – default camera/lens auto sharpening and auto lens corrections
  • Photolemur – it does what it does. There is no control over it. At this point we’ll see the final Photolemur image as there is no way to ask it to only do the sharpening.
  • Lightroom – its default sharpening and lens corrections.
  • Exposure X3 – its default sharpening and lens corrections.
  • Luminar – its default sharpening and lens corrections.
  • Smart Photo Editor – This tool provides a number of user-define sharpening presets. I used Subtle Sharpen as we don’t want to overdo things at this stage.

The inclusion of these processing steps affected the time taken to process the images. Development times were:

[wpdatatable id=6]

Lightroom is still the fastest, but what about the results?

The Results

There’s no doubt about it, when the images are compared below, that DXO has produced the sharpest results. This isn’t surprising as DXO has the smartest algorithm of the RAW converters – it sharpens the image according to its knowledge of the camera/lens combination and selectively sharpens areas of the image according to its needs. Unsharp mask sharpening is global by comparison.

The important thing to note is that none of the converters have over sharpened the image. At this stage in the workflow, it’s better to under sharpen the image than to overdo it. More sharpening can, and will, be applied later.

Photolemur’s final result is shown here – it doesn’t allow for any tweaking of what it does. The final image looks pretty decent to me. Interestingly, Photolemur can (as can the other tools tested here) process regular images such as TIFF and JPEGs and it’s instructive to see what it does with the DXO output image, for instance. But more on that later.

In the following table, you can see full size sections of the image and you can compare the results.

Results – the images

[wpdatatable id=4]

You can view larger sections of the results below. Click the arrows top right for a full screen view.

[URISP id=164]

What’s next?

The image is showing a fair bit of noise, especially in the water. So the next test will be to see how the RAW converters handle it whist still keeping the image sharp and detailed…

Please Support Us

This site supports me and my family.

Please use our links to visit the vendor’s pages. It helps us at no extra cost to you.

Please contribute or send a gift, because that will help me to keep this site active.

All content is Copyright Andy Bell 2024

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related posts

Photo Software Reviews, Topaz Labs

Topaz Photo AI 3 – Quick Review

Topaz Photo AI 3 Hands-on Review Topaz Photo AI 3 is the newest version of Topaz Labs' robust photo enhancement software. This update promises more sophisticated AI-driven tools for noise reduction, sharpening, and upscaling. In this hands-on review, I'll explore the new features and overall user experience to determine if it meets expectations. In my [...]

|Jun 3, 2024

Focus stacking, Luminar NEO, Photo Software Reviews, Photography techniques

Focus Like a Pro: Luminar NEO for Photographers

Focus Like A Pro with Focus Stacking - Luminar NEO tested Focus stacking is a technique used by photographers to achieve a greater depth of field in their images. This method involves taking multiple photos of the same scene, each with a different focus point, and then combining them into a single image with sharpness [...]

|Feb 21, 2024

Luminar NEO, Photo Software Reviews

Unleash Your Imagination: Exploring the Power of Luminar Neo AI for Photographers

Introduction to Luminar NEO AI for Photographers Luminar NEO AI is an impressive photo editing software that incorporates advanced artificial intelligence features. It takes photo editing to a whole new level with its intuitive AI-powered tools. With Luminar NEO AI, editing becomes a breeze as it automatically enhances images, corrects imperfections, and optimizes colors with [...]

|Jan 19, 2024

DXO Photo Lab, DXO Pure RAW
DXO Photo Lab 7

DXO Photo Lab 7 Review

DXO Photo Lab 7 Review This is a look at DXO Photo Lab, a review of its features. This time, I am not comparing it to anything else, although I will refer to comparisons I have made previously, when appropriate. Introduction to DXO Photo Lab 7 DXO Photo Lab 7, which I will simply refer [...]

|Jan 6, 2024

DXO Photo Lab, DXO Pure RAW, Luminar NEO, Photo Software Reviews, RAW Conversion, Skylum Luminar, Software Reviews, Topaz Labs, Topaz Photo AI

The ‘Holy Trinity’ of Photography Software

This blog post looks at the 'holy trinity' of photography software. Three products that, when combined, provide everything you need to develop your RAW images and edit your photos. There is some overlap between the three, as each continues to add to and refine their capabilities. Yet I don't view them as competing with each [...]

|Dec 5, 2023

A.I. Gigapixel, DeNoise AI, DXO Photo Lab, Gigapixel AI, Photo Ninja

Noise Wars – Who Is Winning? DXO Photo Lab 6 vs Topaz Photo AI

Introduction There are only two contenders in the noise wars (IMHO) – DXO Photo Lab and Topaz DeNoise/Photo AI. These two have class leading image noise reduction and I have reviewed them numerous times. Towards the end of 2022, both DXO and Topaz issued new versions of their products. DXO released Photo Lab 6 with [...]

|Jan 21, 2023

Cookie Consent with Real Cookie Banner